Union-Philanthropic Literary Society
Union-Philanthropic Literary SocietyHampden-Sydney College · Est. 1789
Debates every Sunday at 6 p.m.
Draft site. Highlighted text is placeholder content to replace before launch.

Hampden-Sydney College · Founded 1789

The Union-Philanthropic Literary Society

The oldest student organization at Hampden-Sydney and the oldest debating society in continuous operation in the United States. Every Sunday evening the Society debates a resolution in public, and everyone in the room votes.

Sundays · 6 p.m. · The Hall, Schaeffer House

The Union Society

Concordiæ Societas

Established 22 September 1789

Me socium summis adjungere rebus

I wish to ally myself with the greatest things.

United1929

The Philanthropic Society

Fraternitas Philanthropica

Founded March 1805 · re-established 1807

Aude sapere

Dare to be wise.

The Society

Founded the year Washington took office

The Union Society was established on 22 September 1789. The Philanthropic Society followed in 1805. For more than a century the two were rivals: they competed for members, furnished their halls to outdo each other, and built libraries of classical authors, English literature, and rare books. By 1835 the Philanthropic library was larger than the College's own. In September 1929 the two merged under Graves Thompson, then president of the Philanthropic Society, and both continue today as one society.

The purpose has stayed the same. Members get better at speaking and reasoning by doing it every week, in public, in front of people who disagree with them.

Founded
22 September 1789 (Union) · 1805 (Philanthropic)
United
September 1929
Debates
Sundays at 6 p.m., open to everyone
Hall
Schaeffer House
Colors
Light blue and silver (Union) · dark green and gold (Philanthropic)
Records
113 volumes of minutes, rolls, and accounts, 1789–2007, in the College archives

Every Sunday

Come to a debate

Debates are open to every student, professor, and guest. Anyone may speak from the floor, and at the end everyone in the room votes on the resolution. You don't need any experience in speech or debate. Dress is coat and tie.

See this week's resolution

Every Sunday

Notes on procedure for weekly debates

The debate

  • The debate runs about an hour, with three speeches in affirmation of the resolution and three in negation, alternating back and forth.
  • Each speech is three minutes long and is followed by about seven minutes of questioning.
  • The President hosts the questioning. Every question is addressed to the President, without the second-person pronoun “you.”

The vote

  • Everyone in attendance may vote, and is encouraged to.
  • Votes are cast on the quality of the speeches, not on the opinion of the topic one held on entering the Hall.
  • A vote may be cast in affirmation, in negation, or, for the yellow-bellied coward, in absentia.

Joining

Membership is by summons

There is no application. The Society looks for an interest in public discussion, a thirst for learning, a friendly manner, and good character, and it finds those qualities in the people who come to its debates and take part.

  1. Attend

    Come to the Sunday debates and speak from the floor.

  2. Summoned as a Junior

    Each term the Society summons a few regular participants to join as Junior Members.

The Society also elects Honorary Members from among public figures and scholars whose work it judges exemplary.

Customs

Traditions

The preamble at the tree

Each fall, members gather at the Society's tree beside the Watkins Bell Tower, planted about fifty years ago, to read the preamble to the Philanthropic Society's constitution.

The monument

Built in 2026 beside the tree, from bricks left over from the Pauley Science Center. Two alumni of the Society, Michael Van Citters ’22 and James Garrison ’22, helped bring it about.

The collection

The Society keeps paintings of Founding Fathers and early trustees of the College, along with the thrones, reredos, and dais of its Hall. Its historic books are on the fourth floor of Bortz Library, readable in the stacks.

From the roll

Members of note

  • William Henry Harrison
    Union · Class of 1791

    Ninth President of the United States; among the Union Society's earliest members.

  • Edward Henry
    Union · early member

    Son of Patrick Henry, a founding trustee of the College.

  • John Peter Mettauer
    Philanthropic · Class of 1811

    Re-established the Philanthropic Society in 1807; later a noted surgeon.

  • Graves Haydon Thompson
    Philanthropic · 1927

    Led the 1929 merger; taught Latin at Hampden-Sydney for 54 years, the longest tenure in the College's history.

  • Francis Schaeffer
    Union-Philanthropic · 1935

    Theologian and founder of the L'Abri community in Switzerland.

  • John Luster Brinkley
    Union-Philanthropic · 1959

    Rhodes Scholar, professor of classics, and historian of the College.

Fall 2026

Current Membership

The Senior Members, who have delivered their oration and been inducted into full membership, and the Junior Members preparing to join them. The officers are elected by the Membership at the end of each semester.

Officers and Senior Members

  • Satchel Bowling

    Satchel Bowling

    President · Class of 2027

    Convenes and presides over the Society and represents it in public.

    [Bio: two or three sentences, such as hometown, major, when he was inducted, and his oration topic.]

  • Aaron Tong

    Aaron Tong

    First Reviewer · Class of 2028

    Advises on procedure, takes the roll, and keeps order at meetings. Presides when the President is absent.

    [Bio: two or three sentences, such as hometown, major, when he was inducted, and his oration topic.]

  • Knox Burton

    Knox Burton

    Second Reviewer · Class of 2028

    Looks after the Hall and the Society's property.

    [Bio: two or three sentences, such as hometown, major, when he was inducted, and his oration topic.]

  • Charles Palmer

    Charles Palmer

    Clerk · Class of 2028

    Keeps the minutes, the archives, and the Society's correspondence.

    [Bio: two or three sentences, such as hometown, major, when he was inducted, and his oration topic.]

  • William Wallis

    William Wallis

    Treasurer · Class of 2027

    Keeps the accounts, prepares the budget, and directs fundraising.

    [Bio: two or three sentences, such as hometown, major, when he was inducted, and his oration topic.]

  • Dr. Marc Hight

    Dr. Marc Hight

    Critic · Thompson Professor of Philosophy

    The member of the faculty who serves as the Society's advisor.

Junior Members 22 this term

  • John Cale Allen
  • Mark Anderson
  • Hampden Brannon
  • Harrison Brooks
  • William Cole
  • Sebastian Cruz
  • Walker Edens
  • James Etherington
  • Sammy Goins
  • Harrison Inman
  • Owen Kahn
  • Nick Koman
  • Kadin McCallum
  • Mac Montgomery
  • Everett Morse
  • Vincent Palmeri
  • Matthew Piculell
  • Maximus Robinson
  • Samuel Schley
  • William Smiley
  • Harlow Thompson
  • Matty Walker

Weekly debates

Resolutions

A new resolution every Sunday at 6 p.m. in the UPLS Hall at Schaeffer House. Free and open to the public, coat and tie. Anyone may speak, and everyone present votes.

The Union- PhilanthropicSociety

Resolved:

Jury Nullification Undermines Justice.

Sunday, October 18, 2026
6 PM, UPLS Hall at
Schaeffer House

This is a topic for debate and not the official stance of the Union-Philanthropic.

Dress code is coat and tie

Free and Open to the Public
For more information please contact Satchel Bowling, bowlings27@hsc.edu.

No debate on Sunday, October 11, during the College's fall break.

From the minute books

Five volumes, five resolutions

One question from each of five volumes of the Union and Philanthropic minutes, with the date it was argued and how the Society decided it. A new set appears every Sunday at midnight Eastern.

    Questions and decisions are given as the Society recorded them, with spelling and punctuation corrected.

    2026–27

    Events

    The Society's gatherings beyond the weekly debate.

    • Homecoming Alumni Reunion

      Date
      Saturday, October 17, 2026
      Time
      11 a.m.
      Place
      The Hall, Schaeffer House

      Alumni of the Society are invited back to the House during Homecoming Weekend. [RSVP details.]

    • The President's Ball

      Date
      [Saturday, April DD, 2027]
      Time
      6 p.m.
      Place
      Bortz Library
      Dress
      Black tie

      The Society's formal spring ball. Invited guests may bring a companion. Heavy hors d'oeuvres and refreshments, with dancing to follow. [RSVP deadline and contact.] See the invitation and details.

    • Convocation

      Date
      [Day, Month DD]
      Time
      [Time]
      Place
      [Place]

      [One or two sentences on what Convocation is and who attends.]

    • Weekly debate

      Time
      6 p.m.
      Place
      The Hall, Schaeffer House
      Dress
      Coat and tie

      Free and open to the public. See the resolutions.

    Events President's Ball

    Concordiæ Societatis Sigilla Fraternitatisque Philanthropicæ

    The Union-Philanthropic Society

    requests the presence of your company and a guest

    at the

    President's Ball

    Saturday, the [Date] of April

    Beginning at Six O'Clock

    Bortz Library

    at Hampden-Sydney College

    Heavy Hors d'oeuvres and Refreshments

    with dancing to follow

    R.S.V.P. by the [date]
    [RSVP link or email]

    Black Tie Attire

    Spring 2027

    Details

    Date
    [Saturday, April DD, 2027]
    Time
    6 p.m.
    Place
    Bortz Library, Hampden-Sydney College
    Dress
    Black tie
    Guests
    Each invitee may bring a guest
    Fare
    Heavy hors d'oeuvres and refreshments, with dancing to follow
    R.S.V.P.
    [Deadline, and the QR code or email for replies]

    Questions about the Ball go to upls1789@gmail.com.

    The Society in pictures

    Photos

    Debates, the Hall, and the Society's events.

    A member speaking at the lectern in the Hall A member in a gown speaking at a lectern Members in jackets and a gown in the library rotunda A member in a gown seated in an officer's chair before the red curtain Members at commencement The Union-Philanthropic Literary Society banner with both seals A member in black tie speaking at a lectern in the library Three members in black tie Members in black tie at the President's Ball Three members in black tie in the library Two members in black tie Two members in black tie A member in black tie with a guest Members on the lawn by a brick bell tower

    The Hall at Schaeffer House

    Schaeffer Bunker Restoration

    Concept drawings for restoring the Society's debate hall. Plan A keeps the current room and reworks its seating for 69. Plan B removes the restrooms and moves the left wall out 70″, with tiered seating for 74.

    Revision
    3 October 2026
    Ceiling
    103″ at the eaves, 141″ at the ridge
    Scale
    Drawn to scale; all dimensions in inches
    • Society chair
    • Officer's chair
    • Dais
    • Oak paneling, floor to ceiling
    • Seating tiers +6″, +12″, +18″ and +24″ (B only)
    • Wooden riser +18″ (A only)
    • Wooden riser +9″ (A only)
    • Chandelier overhead (B only)
    • Numbered item, see key under C
    • Thompson lectern
    • Rug
    • Window
    • Door opening
    • Room center line
    • Floor drain

    AProposed Layout Without Substantial Bunker Modification

    232″ × 307″
    MEN’SWOMEN’S150″150″70″70″HVACCLERK232″307″257″66″ clear13PRESIDENT1ST REVIEWER2ND REVIEWER21451514+9¼″+6″+6″+9″+9″+9″+9″+18″+18″+18″+18″121011FRONT DOORSSIDE DOOR
    69Total seats, officers included

    Restrooms stay, each 150″ along the wall and drawn 70″ deep, and so does the 47″ × 28½″ HVAC closet between their doors. Three straight rows run down each side from the dais end to the front wall, facing a 66″ clear aisle, with a rectangular rug down the aisle and the Thompson lectern 72″ closer to the doors than in B. There is no center table. The outer row on each side sits on an 18″ wooden riser, with a 9″ step in front of it carrying the middle row; neither runs in front of the restroom doors. On the left it stops short of the men's room door, leaving open floor from there to the HVAC closet, and picks up again near the far end of the women's room door, so most of that doorway is open floor too. The Philanthropic Society Mirror hangs on the front wall between the doors and the right riser, and the Dean Garland portrait hangs on the other side, between the doors and the left riser. On the left riser, which runs up to the men's room door jamb, the Additional Senior Member sits in the back-left corner, then the Treasurer, then the Society Critic. The Clerk sits at the head of the right riser, directly across the room from the Treasurer, with the clerk's desk in front of him on an 18″ step-out of the same riser. The Reviewers sit closer in, in front of the backdrop columns, each on a white 6″ stage beside the dais that wraps around the column base back to the wall (neither has a side table in A). The Shakespeare bust stands on the right 18″ riser between the Clerk's chair and the back wall, turned to face the room. There is no bookcase in A, and every riser runs right back to the back wall. The rows run straight across both restroom doors and the side door, breaking only at the closet.

    BExpanded Hall – with men’s and women’s restrooms removed

    302″ × 307″
    CLERK8302″307″185″48″ clear139PRESIDENT1ST REVIEWER2ND REVIEWER21345614+18″+18″+24″+24″+6″+12″+6″+12″+6″121011FRONT DOORSSIDE DOOR
    74Total seats, officers included

    Restrooms and closet removed, left wall moved out 70″. An octagonal marble center table stands on the rug halfway between the dais and the Thompson lectern. The banks step up in 6″ tiers: inner row on the floor, middle row +6″, outer row +12″, and in each front corner an 18″ tier behind the outer row carries a fourth row: six chairs on the left, three on the right, where the tier stops short of the landing inside the front doors. Behind that, a 24″ tier fills each front corner out to the walls and carries a fifth row of two chairs a side, again kept clear of the landing. The clerk's desk group sits on its own +6″ platform, and the Senior Member filing cabinet stands in the back-right corner. The clerk's desk sits just below the dais on the right, facing the center, with four chairs along the wall behind it. The bank rows run in front of the side door, which closes it off. The Philanthropic Society Mirror hangs on the back wall in the back-left corner, above the Society Critic. There are no bookcases. The front doors stay in their current spot, 35″ right of the new centerline, so the entry gap sits slightly left of them.

    CDais end, front elevation

    Drawn at B's width
    9¼″87″44″32″42″63″27″64″60″60″60″60″31st Reviewer's table1st Reviewer1Dais and ottomanPresident2nd Reviewer4Shakespeare bust14Philanthropic Society Mirror2Backdrop: fluted columns, curtained door52nd Reviewer's table6Senior Member filing cabinet7Portraits over the Reviewers9Center table, ghosted in frontRIDGE · 141″SLOPED CEILINGBACK WALL · 103″Chandelier12 CANDLES · 32″ WIDEINSPIRED BY VENABLEHALL AND JOHNSAUDITORIUMBEAMS 12″ WIDE
    1. 1
      Dais and ottomanWhite wood, 47½″ × 48″, 9¼″ high. The throne is centered on it with the 13″ × 13″ ottoman in front.
    2. 2
      BackdropWhite wood, 70″ wide, 87″ above the dais. Fluted columns, crown molding and a curtained door.
    3. 3
      First Reviewer's table16″ × 16″, 32″ high, white marble top. Lamp in the center and a small stack of books. B only.
    4. 4
      Shakespeare bust21″ bust on a 42″ fluted stand, 63″ overall. In A, on the right 18″ riser between the Clerk's chair and the back wall, turned to face the center of the room; in B, halfway between the Second Reviewer's chair and the right wall.
    5. 5
      Second Reviewer's table23″ × 12″, 27″ high, with a lamp and books. In A, up on the right 18″ riser with its long side against the back wall, between the clerk's desk and the bust; in B, against the right wall.
    6. 6
      Senior Member filing cabinet17¼″ × 17¼″, 64″ high, six drawers with center bar pulls. Back-right corner, B only.
    7. 7
      PortraitsOne over each Reviewer: the dark-framed portrait on the First Reviewer's side, the gilt-framed one on the Second's.
    8. 8
      ChandelierBrass, two tiers, 12 candles, 32″ across, hanging from the ridge at the room's center. Inspired by Venable Hall and Johns Auditorium. B only.
    9. 9
      Center tableOctagonal, 42″ across the flats and 29″ high. Black marble top with white and brown veining on a dark mahogany candlestick pedestal with four carved feet. On the rug, halfway between the dais and the lectern. B only.
    10. 10
      Society CriticOfficer's chair. In B, at the head of the left outer row nearest the dais, on the +12″ tier; in A, third along the left riser, past the Treasurer.
    11. 11
      TreasurerOfficer's chair beside the Society Critic, on his right. On the +12″ tier in B.
    12. 12
      Additional Senior MemberOfficer's chair matching the clerk's. In A, at the head of the left riser in the back-left corner, beside the Treasurer; in B, directly to the clerk's left on his +6″ platform.
    13. 13
      Thompson Philosophy Professorship lectern45″ tall: a 2″ black top with a slight slope toward the speaker, round brown molding, four tapered square legs. About 18″ × 15″ (estimated). 257″ from the back wall in A, 185″ in B.
    14. 14
      Philanthropic Society MirrorGilt rectangular frame, about 42″ × 21″, with an eagle at the top center. In A, on the front wall, centered between the front doors and the right riser; in B, on the back wall in the back-left corner, centered about 62″ up.
    15. 15
      Dean Garland portraitSmall square portrait of a woman in a hat, about 16″ × 16″ (estimated). Front wall, centered between the left riser and the front doors. A only.

    DSection through B's tiered banks

    B only · looking toward the dais
    6″6″130¾″Inner row · floorMiddle row · +6″Outer row · +12″Inner rowMiddle rowOuter rowCenter tableSLOPED CEILING BEYONDOAK PANELING ON EVERY WALLSightlines to the President

    Cut 112″ from the back wall, through the straight part of both banks. Ceiling here is 130¾″. Seated figures use a 31″ eye height above the seat; the dashed lines show the middle and outer rows looking over the heads in front to the President.

    EView from the front doors

    B only · standing eye height 64″

    Standing just inside the front doors where B reads 48″ clear, eyes 64″ up, looking straight down the aisle to the dais. The paneling on the right is cut around the existing 37″ × 45″ windows (sill 40″, head 85″): the farthest shows in full, the second runs off the edge and the third is beside you. Back-wall items are drawn flat at the wall, and the back-wall windows are left out as in C and D.

    Furniture

    PiecePlan size (W × D)HeightWhere
    Society chair (rush seat, ladder back)19″ × 15″Seat 20½″, back 36″Bank seats and the row behind the clerk
    Officer's chair (upholstered armchair)23½″ × 22″Seat 21″, back 44″President, Reviewers, Clerk, Critic, Treasurer, Senior Member
    Thompson lecternAbout 18″ × 15″ (est.)45″, 2″ black topCenter aisle; 257″ from back wall in A, 185″ in B
    Center table (black marble, mahogany)42″ octagon29″B only, on the rug
    Clerk's desk (medium brown)27½″ × 18″33″, sloping to 30″Right bank, facing the center
    Dais (white wood)47½″ × 48″9¼″President
    Backdrop (columns, curtained door)70″ wide87″ above the daisBehind the President
    Reviewers' stages (A only, white)About 25″ × 49″ each6″Either side of the dais
    Ottoman13″ × 13″7½″In front of the throne
    First Reviewer's table (white marble top)16″ × 16″32″B only, at the First Reviewer's right
    Shakespeare bust on standBust 15″ wide21″ on a 42″ standOn the right riser by the Clerk in A; beside the Second Reviewer in B
    Second Reviewer's table23″ × 12″27″On the right riser against the back wall in A; right wall in B
    Desk lamps (two in B, one in A)12″ wide12″On the Reviewers' tables
    Oak panelingAbout 2″ deepFloor to ceilingEvery wall, cut at doors and windows
    Right-wall windows (three, existing)37″ wideAbout 45″Sill 40″, head 85″ (assumed)
    Seating tiers (B only)32″ treads+6″, +12″, +18″, +24″Middle and outer rows, clerk's platform; +18″ fourth row and +24″ fifth row in the front corners
    Side risers (A only, wood)33″ deep18″Under the outer row along each side wall
    Middle-row risers (A only, wood)About 30½″ deep9″In front of the 18″ risers, under the middle rows
    HVAC closet (A only, existing)47″ × 28½″Floor to ceilingLeft wall, between the restroom doors
    Chandelier (brass, 12 candles)32″ acrossHangs to 103½″Room center, B only; after Venable Hall and Johns Auditorium
    Ceiling beams (five, oak)12″ × about 8″103″ wall to 141″ ridge60″ apart, middle one on the dais, B only
    Senior Member filing cabinet17¼″ × 17¼″64″, six drawersBack-right corner, B only
    Portraits (two)34″ × 41″, 30″ × 36″Centered 75″ upOver the Reviewers
    Philanthropic Society Mirror (gilt, eagle)21″ wide42″Front wall in A; back wall, back-left corner in B
    Dean Garland portrait (A only)About 16″ × 16″ (est.)Hung on the wallFront wall, left of the doors
    Floor (wide-plank oak)8″ boards–Throughout

    Giving

    Support the Society

    Gifts from members and alumni support the Hall, the weekly debates, and the Society's events. The Society is now raising money to renovate its debate hall at Schaeffer House over the next several years.

    Renovate the Hall

    [What the renovation covers – seating, lighting, restoration of the dais, and so on – and the timeline.]

    See the concept drawings for the Hall

    Goal
    [$ amount]
    Timeline
    1.5 to 5 years
    Questions
    William Wallis, Treasurer, at wallisw27@hsc.edu

    The Society has done this before. It raised the money to restore Hampden-Sydney's Birthplace (c. 1756) and used it as its museum and meeting place from 1961 until it outgrew the building in 1992.

    Give online

    QR code
    to come
    [Giving link]

    Scan the code or use the link. Gifts go to the Union-Philanthropic Literary Society.

    Since 1789

    Where the Society has met

    1. EarlyWinston Hall – the Patrick Henry Room, on the top floor
    2. To 1957Cushing Hall and McIlwaine Hall. The Society held McIlwaine's third floor until the building burned in 1957.
    3. 1961–92The Birthplace, restored with money the Society raised
    4. TodayThe Hall at Schaeffer House

    Not all locations included.